Article
November 16, 2026
Society, trust, and legitimacy in critical infrastructure resilience
Understanding the roles society, trust, and legitimacy play in critical infrastructure resilience.

Contact our expert

Patrick Moloney
Global Director, Sustainability & Resilience Advisory
Reliable infrastructure does not necessarily mean a resilient society. As electrification and digitalisation deepen our dependence on interconnected services, disruption can have greater consequences – even where performance remains strong. Resilience therefore depends on trust, legitimacy, societal preparedness, and governance as well as engineering. No individual operator can provide it alone.
Greater dependence, less capacity to cope
Reliable infrastructure often goes unnoticed until it fails. Payments, prescriptions, heating, journeys, and messages depend on systems that most people rarely encounter directly. Their reliability can encourage an assumption of uninterrupted service, while electrification, digitalisation, and efficiency reduce the alternatives available when disruption occurs.
This creates a preparedness paradox. Systems can perform better while people and organisations become less able to function without them. Changes that have delivered substantial economic and social benefits have also reduced some of society’s capacity to absorb interruption.
The preparedness paradox. Greater dependence and fewer alternatives can increase the societal consequences of disruption, even where infrastructure remains highly reliable

Unchanged availability and restoration targets can therefore coexist with growing societal exposure. Leaders need to compare credible recovery times with how long essential users can sustain minimum service. Better performance within an operator’s organisation cannot, on its own, close gaps in preparedness elsewhere. Restoring service to most users within a day can still leave a minority facing prolonged disruption. As an outage continues, welfare needs can become urgent and disruption can spread to dependent services.
Trust and legitimacy as resilience infrastructure
Public confidence develops through everyday performance, honest communication, and the treatment of affected users. During disruption, trust supports cooperation, confidence in official guidance, and acceptance of temporary restrictions. Doubt can leave room for rumour and make the response harder to coordinate.
Trust is confidence in an operator’s competence and information. Legitimacy matters too, because people may understand the technical reasons for a restoration decision while questioning whether its consequences are fair. Discussing priorities with authorities, emergency services, other operators, and essential users before an event can make difficult decisions easier to understand and help others prepare. It cannot remove technical limits or guarantee agreement.
Trust as a resilience multiplier. Similar disruptions can produce materially different societal outcomes under high-trust and low-trust conditions.

Public support for resilience does not automatically mean acceptance of the costs and construction needed to deliver it
Global Director, Sustainability & Resilience Advisory
The consequences extend beyond the immediate response. A loss of legitimacy can weaken future cooperation and make investment and funding more contested, constraining efforts to address the vulnerabilities a disruption has exposed.
Agreeing what resilience requires
Citizens expect essential services to be affordable, reliable, sustainable, secure, and resilient. These objectives can reinforce one another, but stronger protection also involves costs and trade-offs. Operators face climate hazards, evolving cyber threats, geopolitical uncertainty, and supply-chain pressures while energy and digital transitions change demand and dependencies.
An expectation deficit emerges where demands for continuity outpace the capability, funding, and preparedness available to support them.
The expectation deficit. A gap emerges where expectations for continuity exceed the capability, funding, and societal preparedness available to sustain it

Clearer expectations must accompany better capability, not substitute it. Candour about limitations is credible only alongside competent management and action on avoidable weaknesses. Promising continuity beyond what the system and its users can support risks undermining confidence when disruption occurs.
Closing this expectation deficit requires a clearer resilience social contract. Governance, regulation, and funding arrangements developed under different assumptions about dependence and risk may need to evolve. Government, regulators, operators, and users must agree who funds additional protection, what disruption is tolerable, and who prepares to manage the remaining consequences.
In principle, support for resilience does not guarantee consent for a new mast, pipeline, site, or tariff increase. Investment cases must connect proposed measures to the societal consequences they would reduce, explain costs and benefits, and acknowledge the exposure that remains. They must remain proportionate as dependence and risk evolve throughout an asset’s life. The case should show how long a credible interruption could last, how long essential users could maintain minimum service, what it would cost to close the gap and who would pay.
Priorities for infrastructure leadership
- Assess continuity against society’s capacity to cope. Compare credible recovery times with how long essential users can sustain minimum service, accounting for changing needs as disruption continues.
- Build relationships before an event. Work with authorities, essential customers, and communities to clarify responsibilities, agree realistic expectations, and support preparedness and trusted communication.
- Build understanding of resilience investment. Explain the consequences it would reduce, the funding and consent it requires, and the limits that remain.
The leadership task is to understand how society’s dependence is changing, agree who will manage the consequences when continuity is lost, and sustain the confidence and consent needed to strengthen infrastructure before the next event.
FAQ
Contact our expert

Global Director, Sustainability & Resilience Advisory
Explore similar insights
RELATED INSIGHTS
Criticality changes the questions leaders need to ask
Learn more about Criticality changes the questions leaders need to askAs organisations across Europe are designated as Critical Entities under the Critical Entities Resilience Directive (CER), resilience is moving from the risk register to the boardroom.
